Critical Moves Podcast - Strategy Videogames (Critical Moves Podcast)

In Episode 21 of Critical Moves, we skip the Civilization VII complaints (we covered that in Episode 18) and get straight to the good stuff—better alternatives. If Civ VII isn’t cutting it for you, we’ve got a list of strategy games that deliver a stronger, more satisfying experience.

Key topics include:

• 4X games that improve on the Civilization formula.
• Grand strategy games that offer deeper mechanics and more engaging long-term play.
• Underrated gems that deserve more attention from strategy fans.

Whether you’re looking for a fresh take on empire-building or just something to fill the Civ VII-shaped void, we’ve got plenty of recommendations. Expect a mix of classics, modern standouts, and a few surprises.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

Critical Moves is a strategy gaming podcast. Each week an eclectic group of gamers come together to discuss the latest in the world of strategy games, from recent releases to classic titles. We dive into everything, exploring game mechanics, tactics and strategies, and emerging trends in strategy videogames. We explore the intricacies of 4X games, the intensity of real-time strategy and the precision of turn-based tactical masterpieces.

As a diverse group you can expect to hear diverse opinions. Each host has a preferred style of games and a unique insight into gaming. No-one claims to be an expert, but we’re dedicated players who love digging into the details, sharing our experiences, and learning along the way. We won’t agree all the time – and wouldn’t it be boring if we did? Our discussions are fuelled by a shared enthusiasm for strategy games and a genuine curiosity about what makes them tick.

So join us every week to hear what hot topics have crossed our desk, and don’t forget to get involved. Join our Discord server or subreddit to speak with the team behind Critical Moves. Share your opinions on strategy games and maybe they will be featured in a future episode, or just tell us we suck.

Be sure to check out our social media accounts too. Remember that liking, commenting, sharing and subscribing not only pleases the algorithm gods but also helps get the word out about us.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

Strategy Game Remasters: Are They Worth It?

In this episode of Critical Moves, we dive into the world of strategy game remasters. We break down how these re-releases breathe new life into classic games and discuss whether they hold up against their original versions.

Key topics include:

• What makes a good remaster and where some fall short.
• Examples like Command & Conquer Remastered and Age of Empires: Definitive Edition—whether they’re just nostalgia plays or genuinely modernized for today’s audience.
• Our thoughts on which strategy games we’d like to see remastered next and how developers are responding to fan demand.

We also cover how remasters can help introduce a new generation to the classics while still satisfying long-time fans of the genre. As usual, we throw in a few rants, differing perspectives, and some strong opinions on remasters versus original releases.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

The RTS Renaissance: Is It Really Happening?

In Episode 2 of Critical Moves, we explore the resurgence of real-time strategy games and whether we’re truly in the middle of an RTS renaissance. We discuss how modern RTS titles revitalized the genre and attracted new players and why indie developers are the salvation of real-time strategy.

Key topics include:

• The evolving mechanics and visuals that have made these newer games stand out.
• How indie developers are keeping the genre alive with fresh ideas.
• Whether nostalgia for classic RTS games plays a role in the resurgence, or if there’s a real innovation driving the trend.

We also debate if this uptick is a passing moment or the start of a new golden age for RTS games. As always, expect some differing opinions, a few rants, and a deep dive into what makes RTS games still relevant today.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 6 of Critical Moves, we explore the iconic strategy games that left a lasting mark on us as players and helped shape the genre. From historic blockbusters to cult classics, we discuss the games that defined our love for strategy and set the foundation for modern RTS and strategy gaming.

Games we discuss include:

• Genre-shaping titles like Red Alert, Total Annihilation, and Age of Empires 2 and how they introduced new layers of strategy.
• Historical favourites like Civil War Generals 2 and War in the Pacific, which offered immersive, detail-rich war simulations.
• Surprises from games like Burden of Command, Suzerain, and Beyond All Reason that highlight the diversity and depth of the genre.
• Newer entries like Sanctuary Shattered Sun that showcase the potential future of strategy gaming.

We share personal stories of what made these games memorable, how they shaped our gaming tastes, and the lessons we learned from each. With a mix of rants, laughs, and debates, this episode is a deep dive into the strategy games that made us who we are as players.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 3 of Critical Moves, we dive into the ongoing debate between fun and realism in strategy games. We discuss how different games navigate this balance, what each approach brings to the table, and how it shapes the player experience.

Games covered include:

• Realism-focused titles like War in the Pacific, Victoria 3, Crusader Kings, King's Order, and Terra Invicta that push for historical or technical accuracy, offering complex, immersive simulations.
• Fun-centric games like Heroes of Might and Magic, Rome: Total War, and Command & Conquer Generals, which focus on exciting gameplay mechanics over strict realism.

We discuss the pros and cons of each approach, why some players love hyper-realistic details while others prefer a streamlined experience, and the challenges developers face in finding a balance. Expect a lively conversation, some rants, and our own takes on what makes a strategy game truly memorable.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 4 of Critical Moves, we explore the evolution of the Total War series, charting its journey from historical epics to fantasy juggernauts and speculating on what’s next for the franchise.

Games discussed include:

• Early classics like Medieval: Total War and Rome: Total War, which set the foundation for the series’ unique blend of grand strategy and real-time battles.
• Modern entries such as the Total War: Warhammer franchise and Empire: Total War, showcasing the series’ shift into fantasy and global conflicts.
• Exciting possibilities for future titles, including fan-demanded settings like Star Wars, World War I, and even the grimdark universe of Warhammer 40K.

We reflect on the series’ impact, its ability to reinvent itself, and what Creative Assembly could do to keep the franchise fresh. Join us for a mix of nostalgia, critique, and wild speculation about the future of Total War.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 5 of Critical Moves, we pitch our ideal strategy games based on some of our favourite franchises. From galactic exploration to post-apocalyptic survival, we brainstorm how these universes could deliver unique and engaging strategy gameplay.

Here’s a taste of what we came up with:

• Bobiverse: A Stellaris-style grand strategy game, where you control a fleet of self-replicating probes exploring the cosmos.
• War of the Worlds: An asymmetrical RTS pitting human resistance against a technologically superior Martian invasion.
• G.I. Joe: A tactical XCOM-like game, commanding the Joes in high-stakes missions against Cobra.
• Game of Thrones: A hybrid of Crusader Kings and Total War, blending political intrigue with large-scale warfare.

We dive deep into how these ideas could expand the strategy genre, with plenty of heated debates and more than a few laughs along the way.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 7 of Critical Moves, we take a look back at the best strategy games released in 2024. From innovative mechanics to unforgettable campaigns, we highlight the titles that stood out and discuss why they deserve recognition.

Without giving too much away, expect:

• Discussions on the year’s standout RTS, turn-based, and grand strategy games.
• A focus on what made these games special, from gameplay innovations to community impact.
• A few surprises, some debates, and our personal favourites.

Whether you're catching up on this year's hits or looking for recommendations, this episode is packed with insights and opinions on the games that defined strategy gaming in 2024.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 8 of Critical Moves, we delve into the ethical dilemmas and moral questions that arise in strategy and wargaming. From historical accuracy to player choices, we explore how morality is woven into the genre and its impact on gameplay.

Key topics include:

• The portrayal of sensitive historical events in games like Civilization and Hearts of Iron.
• Moral choices in strategy games, from diplomacy to resource exploitation, and how they shape outcomes.
• The line between immersive storytelling and potentially problematic themes in wargaming.

We share our thoughts on how games handle these challenges and debate where developers succeed—or fail—in tackling moral complexity. As always, expect passionate discussions, differing perspectives, and a lot of food for thought on the intersection of strategy gaming and ethics.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 9 of Critical Moves, we look forward to 2025 and discuss the strategy games that have us counting down the days. From ambitious indie projects to large-scale epics, we highlight the games poised to make waves in the genre.

Without revealing the full lineup, we cover:

• Highly anticipated titles like Task Force Admiral, Ascent of Ashes, Sanctuary Shattered Sun, and The Last General.
• What excites us about these games, from innovative gameplay mechanics to intriguing settings.
• Speculations on how these releases might push strategy gaming forward in the coming year.

Tune in for a mix of predictions, debates, and plenty of enthusiasm as we explore the games that could define 2025 in strategy gaming.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 10 of Critical Moves, we dive into how storytelling shapes and elevates the strategy gaming experience. Whether it’s through intricate narratives or emergent stories born from player choices, we discuss how games in the genre create memorable and engaging experiences.

Key topics include:

• How storytelling adds depth and emotional weight to strategic decisions.
• The balance between narrative-driven gameplay and player freedom.
• Why storytelling is often underutilized in strategy games and how it could be improved.

Join us as we explore the impact of storytelling on immersion, replayability, and the overall appeal of strategy games. As always, expect thoughtful debates, differing perspectives, and a few passionate rants along the way.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 11 of Critical Moves, we dedicate the entire episode to Stellaris, one of the most influential and ambitious grand strategy games in recent years. From its sprawling galaxies to its endless customization options, we explore what makes this game a standout in the genre.

Key topics include:

• How Stellaris revolutionized the grand strategy formula with its focus on exploration and narrative-driven gameplay.
• A look at its evolution over the years, from launch to its numerous expansions and updates.
• Our favourite mechanics, most memorable moments, and what keeps us coming back for more.

We also discuss the game’s strengths, its challenges, and what we’d like to see in its future. Whether you’re a seasoned Stellaris player or just curious about the hype, this episode offers insights, opinions, and plenty of space-faring enthusiasm.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 12 of Critical Moves, we turn our focus to Paradox Interactive, one of the most prominent publishers in the strategy genre. Known for their complex, immersive games, Paradox has built a reputation for redefining grand strategy and captivating players with deep, long-lasting experiences.

Key topics include:

• A look at Paradox’s signature approach to game design and how it sets them apart in the strategy genre.
• Discussion on the strengths and challenges of their games, from their complexity to their extensive DLC model.
• How Paradox has shaped the modern strategy landscape and fostered a dedicated community of players.

Whether you’re a fan of Paradox’s catalogue or just curious about their impact on the genre, this episode dives into what makes their games unique, why they resonate with players, and what we hope to see from them in the future.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 13 of Critical Moves, we briefly touch on the Stellaris 4.0 update, exploring what’s new and how it’s shaping the game’s future. We then shift our focus to the recent Steam RTS Fest, spotlighting some standout games we think you should check out.

Key topics include:

• A quick breakdown of the Stellaris 4.0 update and its impact on gameplay.
• Highlights from the Steam RTS Fest, featuring our top recommendations for both new and classic titles.
• Why these games caught our attention and what makes them worth playing.

If you’re looking for fresh RTS experiences or want to hear our thoughts on the latest Stellaris update, this episode delivers plenty of insights and recommendations.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 14 of Critical Moves, we get back to basics and talk about actual strategies in strategy games. From defensive turtling to aggressive rushing, we break down different playstyles, their strengths and weaknesses, and where they work best.

Key topics include:

• The eternal debate between turtling and rushing—when to bunker down and when to strike first.
• How different RTS games encourage or punish certain strategies, with examples from classic and modern titles.
• The impact of map design, unit balance, and resource management on strategic choices.

Whether you prefer slow, methodical play or all-out aggression, this episode is a deep dive into the strategic mindsets that shape RTS battles. Expect discussions on familiar games, a few rants, and some strong opinions on what makes a winning strategy.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 15 of Critical Moves, we break down the best strategy games for newcomers to the genre. Strategy games can be intimidating, but some titles do a great job of easing players in while still delivering a satisfying challenge.

Key topics include:

• What makes a strategy game approachable for beginners.
• Our top picks across different subgenres, from RTS to grand strategy.
• How these games teach core mechanics without overwhelming new players.

Whether you're just getting into strategy games or looking for a recommendation for someone new to the genre, this episode is packed with insights on where to start and what to avoid.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 16 of Critical Moves, we take a hard look at why major AAA studios have largely stepped away from real-time strategy games. Once a dominant genre, RTS has seen a decline in big-budget releases, leaving indie developers to carry the torch.

Key topics include:

• The shift in the gaming industry that pushed AAA studios away from RTS.
• Why indie studios are now the driving force behind modern RTS games.

We also discuss whether AAA publishers will ever return to the genre and what it would take to make RTS a mainstream success again. Expect strong opinions, historical context, and a few rants about missed opportunities. And finally, find out how you can join the Critical Moves Podcast team!

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 17 of Critical Moves, we take a deep dive into Sid Meier’s Civilization and its lasting impact on the 4X strategy genre. From its early days to its modern iterations, Civilization has set the standard for explore, expand, exploit, and exterminate gameplay.

Key topics include:

• How Civilization popularized 4X strategy and influenced countless other games.
• The evolution of the series, from the original Civ to its latest instalment.
• What makes the Civilization formula so endearing and enduring.

We also discuss our favourite Civ factions and how Civilization continues to shape the 4X genre today. Expect nostalgia, strong opinions, and plenty of debate about the best ways to lead a civilization to victory.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 18 of Critical Moves, we turn our attention to Civilization 7. With Joe taking the lead on the review and Al asking the tough questions, we break down whether the latest entry in the legendary 4X franchise lives up to expectations.

Key topics include:

• What Civ 7 does differently from its predecessors.
• The gameplay mechanics, AI, and overall balance—what works and what doesn’t.
• Whether this is the evolution the franchise needed or just more of the same.

Does Civilization 7 push the 4X genre forward, or is it playing it too safe? Tune in for Joe’s verdict, Al’s grilling, and a discussion on where the Civ series stands in 2025.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 19 of Critical Moves, we share our experiences from Steam Next Fest, focusing on the strategy games that caught our attention. We played a range of demos, from grand strategy to tactical warfare, and we're here to break down what stood out.

Games covered include:

• Starless Abyss: A FTL inspired roguelite with space combat.
• Task Force Admiral: A well-polished indie game which stinks of AAA awesomeness.
• Orbi Universo II: A super-complex management-simulation-strategy game.
• Roman Triumph: A survival city-builder set in the Roman empire.
• The King is Watching: A roguelite kingdom builder with unique mechanics.
• NWO - Anarchy Collapsed: The absolute worst game to ever exist.

We discuss our first impressions, what we liked (and didn’t like), and which of these games we’ll be keeping an eye on. Expect honest opinions, a few surprises, and our take on what these games might bring to the strategy genre.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 24 of Critical Moves, we get into the long-running debate: turn-based or real-time? Both have shaped the strategy genre in different ways, and we dig into what sets them apart—and why that matters.

Key topics include:

• The differences in pacing, decision-making, and player experience.
• The appeal of control and precision in turn-based games versus the intensity and flow of real-time.
• How each approach affects game design, accessibility, and long-term replayability.

No winner is declared, but we unpack what each style offers and why different players are drawn to one over the other. Clear comparisons, grounded discussion, no fluff.

In Episode 23 of Critical Moves, we dig into Broken Arrow, the modern military RTS that’s been turning heads with its mix of realism and large-scale tactical gameplay.

Key topics include:

• First impressions of the gameplay, interface, and overall design.
• How Broken Arrow compares to other modern military RTS titles.
• What the game gets right—and where it might need more work.

Whether you’re a fan of real-world military hardware or just looking for a solid new RTS, this episode breaks down what Broken Arrow brings to the table and whether it’s worth your time.

Broken Arrow is available to wishlist on Steam and will release in June 2025: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1604270/Broken_Arrow/

In Episode 20 of Critical Moves, we dive into the debate between singleplayer and multiplayer strategy games. We explore what makes each experience unique, why some players prefer one over the other, and how these different approaches shape the strategy genre.

Key topics include:

• The appeal of singleplayer games, from deep narratives to the satisfaction of outsmarting the AI.
• What draws players to multiplayer strategy, including competition, social interaction, and replayability.
• The challenges of toxic communities and how they can impact the enjoyment of multiplayer games.
• Whether it’s possible to create a commercially successful multiplayer strategy game in today’s market.

We share our own experiences, frustrations, and hopes for the future of both singleplayer and multiplayer strategy games. Expect balanced insights, a few rants, and some realistic takes on what it takes to make strategy games thrive in both spaces.

https://criticalmovespodcast.com

In Episode 22 of Critical Moves, we’re joined by a very special guest—Dr. Luke Hughes, the lead developer of Burden of Command, a Leadership RPG launching April 8th on Steam.

We sit down with Luke to discuss:

• The unique mechanics of Burden of Command
• The challenges of remaining authentic but accessible
• Balancing realism, fun and respect in a historical title
• The inspirations behind Burden of Command

Burden of Command launches on 8th of April. Find it on Steam here: https://store.steampowered.com/app/887490/Burden_of_Command/ and support indie game developers.